Review on Transitional Country Dining Table Knotty by Stephanie Bolotova

I bought a set of 4 table legs! Exactly the shape and style we wanted. However, when we dyed them, 2 were redder and 2 were as expected (as in the photo!). If they are all pine, I don't understand why they are colored differently. They were all painted the same color on the same day. Pretty annoying and I'm not sure if we can use them. I really don't want to color them. But unfortunately this might be my only option and it's not the look we're going for.