Although it's a bit small, it's leather and I expect it to stretch a bit to fit perfectly. Incidentally, Nunn Bush shoes have far from ideal consumer ratings. Don't believe it. My current pair has been worn every day in poor conditions. They are still comfortable and hold together well. I just wore them out!
Dansko Wynn Slip Black 8 5 9 Men's Shoes
55 Review
Wool Blend Slippers Heathered Leather Maximum Men's Shoes and Loafers & Slip-Ons
58 Review
Bostonian Bolton Loafer: Sleek Leather Shoes for Men
48 Review
Men's Merrell Jungle Waterproof Slip-On Loafers in Gunsmoke - Shoes for Superior Comfort and Style
47 Review