Review on ALEADER Womens Cold Weather Winter Boots, Waterproof Snow Boots by Joyce Keesling

5 for style, 3.5 for out of box comfort, 3 for wet winter protection. Overall 3.83 rating, rated as a 4 for rounding. Didnt you love when your teacher rounded!I ordered these boots in black and they are very cute. These boots were for a trip to Colorado at the beginning of ski season. Litte did we know we were there for the storm that dumped several inches of snow over Colorado. With that being said the soles of the boot were waterproof as was the shaft. However, the top of the boot, where there are seams that run parallel to the top of your foot are not ! When snow kicked over my foot, the snow melted into the boot leading to a damp foot. The photo shows a more extreme covering of snow but even shallow brief sprays of snow would seep into the top as with light walking near base. Needless to say I decided against tours in the mountains that required ling distance walking. I have a long slinder foot and the boot fit. I added insoles to increase the level of comfort. I wear 8.5 to 9.5 in most shoes. Most of my other boots are a 9 and ordered a 9 in these. If you have difficulty fitting rounded toe shoes, this pair could pose a slight problem.