So these bags are exactly what you are looking for. I bought 9 different tapes. They are soft and have a lot more points to adjust the strap properly. The extra strap is then snapped in like the original strap that came with the watch. BUT it has a buckle! So much more convenient. So far, after wearing it for a few weeks, it shows no signs of wear or damage (I wear it to work and it keeps snagging). 10/10 just wish they had more color and such.
SAMSUNG Galaxy Watch Active2 (Aqua Black, R820-44mm) 📱 with Bluetooth, Silicon Strap, and Aluminum Bezel - International
248 Review
Black Audio-Technica ATH-M50X Professional Grade Studio Monitor Headphones with Detachable Cable - Critically Acclaimed
200 Review
Sennheiser HD280PRO: 🎧 Next-Generation Pro Audio Headphones
260 Review
SAMSUNG Galaxy Buds Live: True Wireless Earbuds with Active Noise Cancelling & Wireless Charging Case - Mystic Bronze (US Version)
252 Review