I would like to give this shoe 5* but had to change it to 4 because of the rubber smell. I ordered the size I usually order - size 11 - and it fits perfectly. I've been wearing it for about 2 weeks now (worn 2 months) and no complaints. Good: - Very comfortable - no need to tie anything. You can slide your feet easily. The tongue is slightly stretchy/flexible. - Very stylish and YOU WILL GET MANY COMPLIMENTS. - I am so satisfied that I am considering buying a second one, but in a different colour. Bad: - If this is your first time receiving this, don't wear it. I made the mistake of wearing it while rushing to work and it looked like a walking smelly rubber tire. Tire odor is very strong. I had to leave it in my garden for a few days and nights before the smell got better. Then I had to leave it in a sunny room that gets some airing for a week due to rainy weather. Even then the smell existed, but to feel it you had to get close to it. Pretty much I let it air out for 1 month and 2 weeks. You can see the lines when the shoe is bent. I don't mind it much, but it's still there. Look at the picture I uploaded. This happened after 2 weeks of gestation. If I knew that, would I buy another one? Yes, it's worth every penny. It doesn't look/feel cheap either.