Overall this Henely shirt with pockets is very well made and about 40% cheaper than my same Sixe 2XL-Tall at Carhartt Henel- Pocket. The fabric seems a little heavier. The main difference is that the Carhartt version has a 3-4 inch longer tail. So when you wear your tails, the Dickeys version looks better because the Carhartt version is actually too long below the waist. But if you tuck half your shirt in your pants, then Carhartt's version is better, so there are no "plumbers," so to speak. However, the Dickies product is of great value.