They had for months. Just noticed the pages are peeling. Both shoes have the same front area. So much for waterproofing. return the favor and the seller must take them back even if the return period has expired in 30 days because they are defective.
Pros
They are still new, so I cannot judge their durability.
Cons
It was raining the first time I wore them. The first puddle I stepped in with my left boot soaked up the water like a sponge.