Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
πŸ‘ž black men's allen edmonds randolph loafer shoes logo

πŸ‘ž Black Men's Allen Edmonds Randolph Loafer Shoes Review

7

Β·

Average

Revainrating 3.5 out of 5Β Β 
RatingΒ 
3.5
πŸ‘ž Men's Loafers & Slip-Ons, πŸ‘ž Men's Shoes

View on AmazonView on Π―M

Media

(4)
img 1 attached to πŸ‘ž Black Men's Allen Edmonds Randolph Loafer Shoes
img 2 attached to πŸ‘ž Black Men's Allen Edmonds Randolph Loafer Shoes
img 3 attached to πŸ‘ž Black Men's Allen Edmonds Randolph Loafer Shoes
img 4 attached to πŸ‘ž Black Men's Allen Edmonds Randolph Loafer Shoes

Description of πŸ‘ž Black Men's Allen Edmonds Randolph Loafer Shoes

100% Leather. Leather and manmade sole. Leather loafer with penny keeper and moccasin-stitched toe. Leather lining. Cork footbed shapes to foot for personalized fit.

Reviews

Global ratings 7
  • 5
    4
  • 4
    1
  • 3
    0
  • 2
    1
  • 1
    1

Type of review

Revainrating 2 out of 5

He didn't like the sole of the shoe

I sent them back because my husband found these shoes uncomfortable. He didn't like the sole of the shoe, saying it was too hard and lacking in support.

Pros
  • With a cushioned sockliner and cushioning midsole, these shoes offer exceptional comfort and all-day support.
Cons
  • Can be uncomfortable with prolonged wear due to lack of padding.

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Classic moccasins with a modern twist that can be worn casual or semi-formal.

I love them because they are the AE brand and what they stand for. They are comfortable, stylish and very durable! I love everything about AE.

Pros
  • EXCELLENT QUALITY: Allen Edmonds Randolph men's shoes are made from premium leather and feature strong stitching for durability and a quality product.
Cons
  • Not suitable for daily wear, more suitable for formal occasions.

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Great shoes I think

This is the second pair, ordered $8.5 but they were too tight. 9 US fits tight but shoes loosen. Take half a size larger than usual. That confusion aside, this is a well made shoe that I expect to wear for a very, very long time.

Pros
  • The 3E width and multiple sizing options provide the perfect fit for those with wider feet, preventing discomfort or irritation.
Cons
  • May not be suitable for those with wide feet or high arches.

Revainrating 1 out of 5

Painfully uncomfortable, poorly finished

I suspect these are standard shoes at Guantanamo unless banned by the Geneva Convention. Aside from the looks of this shoe, I can't find a single positive feature. They are far inferior to the much cheaper shoes I've had in terms of comfort, finish and fit. I've mostly worn Ferragamo loafers for the past few years, but I figured it was time to ditch the flashy buckles and opt for something new. classic and conservative, that's why I chose this design. I was tried on at the AE store on 5th Ave…

Pros
  • Handcrafted in the USA
Cons
  • Limited availability can make it difficult to find replacement pairs or sizes.

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Style change?: Men

I usually wear Edmonds shoes, have had them for over 5 years so am wondering if they have changed style. specified. I think I'll have to go to the store and try them on again before ordering online. I have purchased Nordstroms shoes before and have been very satisfied.

Pros
  • Cool
Cons
  • Damaged

Revainrating 5 out of 5

You get what you pay for

I've been wearing AE shoes for thirty years. I redid the last two pairs of soles and heels at least 4 times. Finally tired of the style. As with any premium leather shoe, you need to know your size. Environments are not all the same. These are great shoes. I just bought two new pairs including this shoe and will continue to buy them for as long as I can afford them.

Pros
  • Best in class
Cons
  • Good but not great

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Happy Feet / Happy Customer

It wasn't until I personally visited Nordstroms to refresh my current wardrobe that I realized I have a wide, high-arched foot. It explained why some of my shoes were uncomfortable and why I had to buy shoes that were bigger than I needed to get the right width. With that realization came the solution to my problem of buying double or triple "E” wide shoes. The only one that sells Nordstrom tires in different widths is Allen Edmonds. These shoes fit me very well! These are the most comfortable…

Pros
  • Durable Finish
Cons
  • Durable