COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner, Midnight Blue: Long-Lasting Precision in a Convenient 0.08 Ounce Size (Pack of 1) Review

Causes stains. It's difficult to use. The advice is strange. It has a plastic cap that guides the eyeliner and breaks the eyeliner. I wouldn't buy it again. waste of money. UPDATE: Still the worst pencil I've ever used. The tips came off and I didn't realize it fell onto my carpet. Now I have a spot that reminds me how bad it is. I wanted to get my money's worth and kept using it, but today I finally threw the two I bought in the trash.

Color was ok. I've never had an eyeliner that bled under my eyes just because of watery eyes. I wear it on my top cap and hardly ever use it. I don't rub my eyes, I just get wet. I use moisturizer but this has never been a problem with my regular brands. Well it was an experiment to see if I could save a few bucks. In my case it's not worth it.

Absolutely terrible product. The container doesn't let you choose how much to use. It clicks so hard when twisted, the tip is flat and fell off when I twisted it to dose. I've tried to apply and it's just smearing not getting a decent application at all. I have never tried such a terrible useless product. Absolutely not to use. Can't believe I was excited to try this eyeliner.

I am 64 years old and have been using dark blue eyeliner for over 40 years but only expensive. I was in a bind and had to order from Revain but they didn't have my brand so I ordered these. WOW!, I was shocked when it turned out to be better than my expensive pencil! This is such a good product and a pleasure to use. Thanks cover girl!

I've been using eyeliner for years including other Covergirl eyeliners and I have to say this is probably the worst eyeliner I've ever used. It smears under the eyes almost immediately. for example within the first minute after application. and I don't have oily skin and I don't use moisturizer around my eyes. It's just WAY too soft or creamy or whatever to stay in place. i will throw it away

The color is nice - a deep navy blue - but definitely not stain resistant or water repellent. To get the hold I had to use a primer, a long-wearing eyeshadow and a setting powder - which might be fine for a night out, but too much for the minimal daily makeup I was looking for. Also, the tip breaks very easily, so I lose a lot of product.