🍪 Wilton 8.5-Inch x 10-Inch Toaster Oven Sheet: Compact and Versatile Baking Tray Review

This is a great product at a great price. This is my third, my extra. I use my toaster a lot more than my stove. Easy to clean in the dishwasher and living in Florida it won't rust in the dishwasher. Rounded edges are important. Thank you!

It's the perfect size for my toaster. The cover is beautiful. However, it warped after the first use and no longer lies flat. It's a bit annoying that it wobbles and cooks unevenly. There is also a hole in the rim, I think that can lead to slight rusting.

I washed it the first time I used it. Even started eating what was baked on it and got clean. However, the second time I used it, I baked mozzarella sticks and left them in the toaster overnight. I went to wash in the morning and never came off. We even tried bleach. Not impressed.

Couldn't find this size anywhere else. The one that came with the oven only lasted a few weeks (weird stuff, unlike any pan I've seen in 40+ years). It lasted almost two months, so I can't say anything about durability yet. I just wash my hands and dry them right away (If you're also looking for pans that fit a similar sized toaster, there's also a Farberware toaster set here that fits perfectly. Not as good as this pan, the sheets are a little smaller. )

It fits (mostly) in a small toaster and is easy to clean, but the odd little bulge on its long side means I can't use it on higher toaster levels where the oven is a bit narrower inside. Would have preferred a uniformly rectangular one, but not serious. Good enough and will work for several months. It seems pretty solid but has started to warp a bit. Given the difficulty of finding small trays like this, I'll probably buy the same brand again when it wears out.

The quality of this toaster toaster was acceptable, but the dimensions are slightly different. Measurements refer to the INSIDE of the sheet, while if you're measuring something that will fit in your toaster, the outside edge will add extra width/length! For me it didn't fit and wasn't acceptable. A NOTICE. The item I received was shipped directly from Bed Bath & Beyond (BB&B). This product is available at a fraction of the price (less than half) when you are ready to drive to the store. If I…