The iMethod Winged Eyeliner Stamp and Liquid Eyeliner is a decent product for the price. I wouldn't describe this as liquid liner, since both the stamp and liner are felt pens. The packaging was detailed, the liner pen and liner stamp were easy to identify. I used the right side and left side of the stamp pen, as well as the thick and thin end of the liner pen this morning before work. The black is dark and so far, as of 8 hours later, still un-smudged and still dark/not faded. I would recommendSee full review