I've gone through about 9 tubes of this and the first three were great (So many because I give one to daycare, a tube in our room, a tube in the nursery). It was effective and smells wonderful. Please note that if your baby is very sensitive, all of Babo Botanicals products are loaded with fragrances and essential oils that could potentially irritate their skin. Natural means nothing and organic does not mean best skincare. Anyway, after the first three tubes all the rest were grainy. I emailed See full review