So I'm giving this a 3 because I have other boots from Arkbird and they are very comfortable and good quality but These shoes the one Should be a size 12 (the same size as my boots), closer to a 10 or 10.5. I have one foot a little smaller than the other and they were unbearably small even for a small man. Styling wise they are very attractive and like I said Arkbird makes really good stuff so either I did something wrong on the label or it's a problem with this particular model of shoe. I won't say I won't buy them, but be prepared to go back and order a different size if needed.