Analog sticks appear to be identical to the original. If you compare them side by side, you will hardly feel the difference. So I think if you hadn't thought about it or even known about the exchange, you would have even noticed. Housings for joysticks are decent enough, I thought they were a giveaway. I'm currently using a white pair, but I may not keep them on my analog sticks. However, the screwdriver in this set is terrible. It's just too small and will start removing screws if you're not careful. Luckily I had another screwdriver of the right size handy and it worked like magic. I advise you to use your own tool or buy one, do not use the one provided here.