Just received these boots. They look good and fit well. The reason for the rating 4, not 5 - shoelaces! The laces are terrible! The aglets are too big for the lace holes and I ripped 2 eye covers out of the boot trying to lace the boot up! I ended up having to cut the laces off my boot and didn't have to go out and buy new laces. Love the boots, hate the fact that I can't wear them yet!