I bought this product to replace a cracked and broken case for my original orange controller. The hull was great. I chose not to use the included wiring harness so it took a little tweaking and it worked. The back is probably not the same as the original. You can see light coming through the plastic. However, I personally expected it that way, but it's worth noting. The included keys are slightly crooked or off-center. I ended up using my original sticks and buttons on a refurbished controller (orange) and the included buttons on another controller (black). The PS button doesn't work and I would recommend keeping the original. For those doing a complete makeover, this can be a visual nuisance. All in all I would recommend this product to anyone looking to rebuild a controller with a similarly colored broken case with the intention of using as many original parts as possible.