Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Nicole Mcleod photo
1 Level
9648 Review
6388 Karma

Review on 🧦 Discover Japanese Stitch Inspirations: Knitted Socks East and West - 30 Exquisite Designs by Nicole Mcleod

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Excellent patterns, poor quality prose

I haven't knitted any patterns from this book yet. I usually read a book first before starting a project. My first impression is that the patterns are very unique but not particularly complicated. However, if you are someone who actually reads the prose in sample books, you may find the prose/story in this book uncomfortable. The author doesn't seem to have done any real research on Japanese culture (in terms of knitting or in general). The book is based on her experience with patterns from Japanese embroidery books. I expected the prose to reflect some level of Japanese knitting culture. Instead, the author admits that her sources for writing the book were "Japanese Words Scrabble and the Internet". and when it came time to name the patterns, she simply made a list of the Japanese words she knew. As a result, patterns have stereotyped names with no deep meaning associated with the pattern, such as Examples: sayonara, geisha, haiku, ninja, samurai, karaoke and sumo. Also, I found some of the samples a bit unrealistic in the materials used. For example, a sock is loosely knitted in a very fine mixture of baby alpaca and silk. However, the book is more than worth the money for the patterns alone. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings. I found some of the patterns a bit unrealistic in the materials used. For example, a sock is loosely knitted in a very fine mixture of baby alpaca and silk. However, the book is more than worth the money for the patterns alone. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings. I found some of the patterns a bit unrealistic in the materials used. For example, a sock is loosely knitted in a very fine mixture of baby alpaca and silk. However, the book is more than worth the money for the patterns alone. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings. I found some of the patterns a bit unrealistic in the materials used. For example, a sock is loosely knitted in a very fine mixture of baby alpaca and silk. However, the book is more than worth the money for the patterns alone. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings. I found some of the patterns a bit unrealistic in the materials used. For example, a sock is loosely knitted in a very fine mixture of baby alpaca and silk. However, the book is more than worth the money for the patterns alone. Also, I like that the patterns shown include a range of yarn weights, not just fingerings.

Pros
  • Dope 🔥
Cons
  • Expensive