These shoes are exactly what I was looking for.
Yes, they're a bit more expensive than the water shoes you can find at the discount store, but if you're looking for safety when crawling over rocks (in or out of the water), these are the shoes. They are very grippy on wet or dry surfaces.
Orange Men's Vibram Ascent Insulated M Sneaker Shoes - Enhanced SEO
45 Review
Steve Madden Fashion Sneaker Fabric Men's Shoes for Fashion Sneakers
54 Review
DREAM PAIRS Liberty M: Lightweight π and Breathable Footwear for Your Active Lifestyle
59 Review
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico Shoes - Men's Grey Sneakers
46 Review