Bought for my husband as a birthday gift, his first pair of guys. In the end he really liked her and it was great! The only drawback to the product are a few loose threads in the material, which unfortunately only turned into many loose threads after wearing it several times. I hope they don't fall apart after a few more socks! I've seen the exact same shoes in stores and haven't noticed a problem with loose threads so I think it might just be a random pair and we'll be buying another pair in the future anyway.