This worked well on a PS2 controller that had the stick tops torn off. They're pretty easy to replace. Just make sure everything, like the trigger/bumper knobs, is lined up again when you reassemble the controller and put the screws back in. Some disassembly is required to replace them. I still have an original Sony controller for the PS2. When comparing these sticks to the original, the texture is very similar. However, Sony's original sticks feel a little soft to my thumbs when they're just made out of hard plastic. There are differences here from the original, but they're very close and better than what was on the broken controller.
Wii Guitar Hero World Tour - Independent Guitar Controller
11 Review
Game console Sony PlayStation 3 Slim 3 320 GB HDD, black
74 Review
Programmable Wireless Switch Pro Controllers With 9-Color RGB LEDs For Switch/Switch Lite/OLED/PC, One-Key Pairing Gamepad With 800MAh Battery And 6-Axis Motion Wake Up Function By VOYEE
13 Review
🎮 Usergaing Wireless Xbox Controller for Xbox Series X/S/One & PC - Blue, Enhanced Gaming Experience with Audio Jack
16 Review