Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Amicz Kakaruk photo
1 Level
1326 Review
38 Karma

Review on Memorex 700MB/80-Minute 52x Data CD-R Media - 50-Pack Spindle by Amicz Kakaruk

Revainrating 1 out of 5

High failure rate, unreadable by some Plextor devices

What an atrocity these drives are. I have three different CD drives:* Plextor PX-755SA (firmware 1.07)* Plextor PX-716A (firmware 1.11)* Toshiba SD-R1612 (firmware version unknown) All discs were burned on PX-755CA. A write failed (maybe just a bad disc; that happens), so I'm ruling that out from my perspective. All writes were done at 16x (sometimes I use faster, but I prefer less rereading when using disc). Of the 10 successful burns, 7 were readable by the PX-755SA, 3 were not readable by all drives (including the PX-755SA). Of the 7 readable discs, only ONE was readable by any drive other than the PX-755SA. Before you say "looks like a problem with Plextor," consider this: however, I have to believe that these drives have serious compatibility issues that have nothing to do with the manufacturer. Maybe I just got a "bad batch," but the marriage percentage is totally unacceptable; it's a waste of money and a waste of time. As someone in IT, I need to be able to burn a disc at an acceptable speed (16x) and ship that disc to shared storage to install an OS on a server. I don't like burning a disc and then driving for 20 minutes only to find that the medium itself has let me down. Avoid those special Memorex discs. However, I have to believe that these drives suffer from serious compatibility issues that have nothing to do with the manufacturer. Maybe, I just got a "bad match" but the marriage percentage is totally unacceptable; it's a waste of money and a waste of time. As someone in IT, I need to be able to burn a disc at an acceptable speed (16x) and ship that disc to shared storage to install the OS on the server. I don't like burning a disc and then driving for 20 minutes only to find that the medium itself has let me down. Avoid those special Memorex discs. As someone in IT, I need to be able to burn a disc at an acceptable speed (16x) and ship that disc to shared storage to install an OS on a server. I don't like burning a disc and then driving for 20 minutes only to find that the medium itself has let me down. Avoid those special Memorex discs. As a person in the IT industry I need to be able to burn a disc at an acceptable speed (16x) and deliver that disc to the shared storage in order to install an operating system on the server. I don't like burning a disc and then driving for 20 minutes only to find that the medium itself has let me down.

Pros
  • For use with 1X-52X speed
Cons
  • Exorbitant price