I don't have thick hair, but I was only able to wrap a rubber band around my hair twice. It's just not very flexible. Since I could only loop it twice, I was able to pull it right out of my straight, slippery hair. It doesn't suit me, but it might suit you.
Brown Velvet Wig Grip Band - Adjustable MainBasics Headband
33 Review
Adjustable Elastic Hair Band For Girls - Hairizone Cosmetics Headband For Shower, Spa, And Face Washing With Bowknot Design (Blue)
33 Review
Coolcos Synthetic Hair Headbands: 5 Strands Elastic Braided Style For Perfect Plaited Look
33 Review
MAYOUTH Microfiber Hair Drying Towels Head Wrap With Bow-Knot Shower Cap Hair Turban HairWrap Bath Cap For Curly Long & Wet Hair Gift For Women 2Pack
46 Review
John Frieda Precision Foam Color Blue Black 2A - Nourishing Permanent Hair Color Kit For Deep Color Saturation & 100% Grey Coverage
19 Review
Temporary Hair Color Chalk Set - 36 Vibrant Colors For Kids, Teens, And Adults - Works On Both Light And Dark Hair - Add Flair To Your Hairstyle
20 Review
Get Ready For Fun With Natural Green Temporary Hair Dye Wax - Ideal For Cosplay, Halloween And Christmas Parties!
18 Review
Remington PG6030 Haircut Kit
23 Review