I would give this product an average rating of 3.5 stars. Pros: It's reasonably priced and we got extra stuff where we intended with minimal fuss. The tote bag is a nice addition. Cons: There is one major design flaw; The large flap covering the zip extends across the front and at high speeds air enters underneath and inflates it, creating noise and drag and compromising waterproofing. (We had gotten some stuff wet in a front corner of the bag otherwise it would have kept our stuff dry. The tighter it ties the quieter but that brings me to the quality. The stitching for the straps isn't good. I have ripped one of the straps half way when I first tightened it I can't speak to the durability as we only used it for about 400 miles (average speed 68-75 mph) but other than that I broke one, before i left cos it had no other damage when we got to our destination finally it will make fuel economy worse we usually get 24+ in our jeep grand cherokee and we only managed 18mpg not really the bags fault I guess I just something to keep in mind, overall the price justifies the purchase if you need something in a pinch like we did and I would recommend it for that but I don't expect it to last more than a trip or three.
Universal SUV Car Top Luggage Holder With Extension - XCAR Roof Rack Carrier Basket Rooftop Cargo Carrier, Black, 64"X 39"X 6
14 Review
20 Cubic Feet Waterproof FieryRed Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier - Anti-Slip Mat, Travel Storage Luggage Bag Soft-Shell For All Vehicles With Or Without Rack
14 Review
Protect Your Vehicle'S Roof With Mockins Rooftop Protector Mat - 37"X55" Cushioned And Gripped Car Roof Protective Mat For Any Cargo Bag, SUV Or Truck
13 Review
CURT Hitch Cargo Carrier - 60 X 20-Inch Basket With 500 Lbs Capacity, Black Steel, 2-In Folding Shank
42 Review