Used analogues: Tamron 17-50 2.8 without VC (on Nikon d90) Not an analogue, but there is also a Canon 50 1.8 (of course it sometimes smears. A very "wide-loose" focus range), but cheap and angry :) and 1.8. And another one that is not at all analogous is whale 18-55 3.5-. now it is covered with dust. For myself, I do not see the disadvantages of this lens at all. It is difficult to compare with the tamron, which I took on my Nikon D90, because. he got caught with a front focus and spoiled the impressions of a vacation trip, however, even if compared in terms of focus / sharpness, in my opinion, the tamron is inferior to sigma in the elaboration of details and their quality level. In general, the main review is all spelled out in the strengths of this device. Very happy with the purchase, I do not regret a second. Excellent lens! Reveals 18mp potential in 550d one hundred percent. As I already wrote - "the lens decides" :).