Since there are only HDMI and VGA as video connectors, your cables must each be one and this product has a design flaw where VGA and HDMI do not fit at the same time. And it's not that "my cables are different": the VGA connectors are pretty much the same, leaving 1mm for the plastic part of the HDMI connector. If there is such a cable that will do the job, which I doubt, you're going to have to spend more money on something that's a design flaw.
Sony DualSense dual controller charging station for PS5 white/black
38 Review
Universal Laptop Docking Station for Windows and Mac - Plugable USB 3.0 Dual DisplayPort 4K Monitor with Gigabit Ethernet, Audio, and 6 USB Ports
12 Review
Experience Seamlessly Connected Productivity: USB C Hub Docking Station with Triple Display, Dual HDMI 4K, DP, PD Charger, Gigabit Ethernet, USB Ports, SD/TF Card Reader - Ideal for MacBook Pro and Windows
11 Review
Dell 452-BCYT D6000 Universal Dock in Black: A Hassle-free Single Solution
17 Review