Overall price, quality and construction are good. I would give them a 5 star rating if they were the right size. They are advertised as 1/2" wide when in fact they are about 3/8" wide. Why is it important? This is a custom size. They are thinner than most other collars and too small to comfortably fit any of my various shirts. Various lengths are suitable, but are too loose in the collar opening to be effective. I will try to return these.