I honestly don't know how to rate these. I've had them for a week or so now and have noticed very inconsistent handling. Joysticks are responsive... and in most games, they're overly responsive. The sensitivity can be nauseating at times when playing the game in first person as the camera moves very quickly. It will also cause serious problems when playing something that requires precision. However, fast scanning of the joystick is sometimes delayed - you can see visible "flashes" that make the movement choppy. All controls feel a little laggy, but they're not useless. I also noticed that the camo/fatigue controller has more lag and other issues than the solid color controller. For the price it's worth it. However, it would be better to lower the quality requirements.