I bought these at a huge discount as they were meant to scratch. NO, they were in perfect condition. The box was a little wrinkled in one corner but they are packed in styrofoam and we are in perfect condition. I installed them on my tractor for more stability and am very happy with their performance. I don't feel as drunk on side slopes, and it pushed out the weighted wheels for the added benefit of traction. I suspect they will last me the life of the tractor.