I used to buy 4 1/2 for my daughter but got a few (5) and she says they hurt. So maybe they're really tight. I recommend going up a whole size!
Felix Flora Toddler Flower Dress Shoes - Adorable and Comfy Flats
47 Review
Adorable Blowfish Malibu Play-t for Toddler and Little Girls
47 Review
Capezio Girls 3800 Mary Jane Tap Shoe in Caramel - Size 11.5 M Toddlers
49 Review
DREAM PAIRS Little Aurora 03 Communion Shoes and Flats for Girls - Top Choice for Stunning Style and Comfort
49 Review