I chose the APDTY shackle because the weld looks and is much better in the photo. Solid looking welds and good finishes. And I did it again! The driver's side had to be replaced first, and last month the passenger's side fell off, so I welded in an APDTY side to replace it. Excellent quality, good welds, I am very happy with their attention to detail. My 31 year old Jeep is alive.