Overall, I enjoy the gloves. They are super warm and have thus far kept my hands quite balmy in the first weeks of cold and snow. They stay nice and warm in the wind and no water has trickled in, which is nice. The only downsides might be that they are a bit expensive, and seem to be long in the thumbs and pointer finger. I might have odd shaped hands but when the thumbs bend back, the ability to use them on a phone is all but useless.