These shoes look very good, I've spent a lot of time looking for a pair that is a similar pair can replace old Sperrys, not many available in size 11W. However, they seem to have a much stiffer/harder top canvas than my old ones and as a result the fabric flexes painfully at my big toe joint when stepping inside. If you never had to walk in them they would be a 5 but given the pain when walking due to the stiffness in the flex of the foot I may have to return them.