I like the caps but they don't fully cover all the metal like the original caps. With these caps there is a gap between the caps and the metal and then the black stem. Not too flashy, but not perfect either.
I bought these for someone as stocking fillers - turns out they love them very much. Just goes to show that we shouldn't buy expensive gifts for men - only something with a little thought. Yes, he loved her as much or more than some of his other, more expensive gifts.