I bought these for 3 Boston Terriers to chew at the office. No complaints on ingredients, packaging, or delivery. They seem kind of like a bully stick that’s been flattened out. My dog can’t have rawhide and he gets really phlegmy with bully sticks. TIPS: This is an outdoor treat only, and supervise your dog!The PROS - the dogs love to chew them, don’t appear to irritate my dog who has allergies to things, easy to break if you don’t want the dog to have a whole stick. They are pretty long.maybe See full review