This is almost what I was hoping for. Completely made of silicone, no plastic, small protective edge. It is tight both vertically (the license plate fits but needs to be inserted carefully and on the last few millimeters with a hammer) and horizontally. I've attached a photo to show the latter, you can see my license plate sticking out from the side, it's actually in the middle and pulling down on either side, but I couldn't capture that in the photo. I think it should be 5mm longer.
Wall bracket Holder LCDS-5038, metallic
12 Review
Set Of 2 Black Aujen Silicone License Plate Frames For US Standard Cars - Street Legal Cover With Easy Installation And Rattle-Proof Holder For Optimal Protection
35 Review
Protect Your Car'S License Plates With Aootf Clear Smoked Novelty Cover And Black Silicone Frame Combo
12 Review
Unbreakable Black License Plate Frame & Cover Combo - Aootf Clear Bubble Novelty Plate Protector To Protect Car Tags, Plates, Screws And Caps.
14 Review
4WD ORCISH Recovery Traction Boards Tracks Tire Ladder For Sand Snow Mud - Set Of 2 (2Nd Gen Bag + Mounting Pins, Black)
39 Review
Nokian Tires Nordman RS2 SUV 225/60 R18 104R winter
32 Review
Nokian Tires Hakka Green 3 205/55 R16 94H summer
37 Review
Yokohama Ice Guard IG50 215/50 R17 99Q winter
36 Review