I have had the black version of this show for years and have repurchased many times. I was dismayed when Cole Khan discontinued this base shoe. I was so happy to find them at Revain but I think the black ones I got are fake. The upper skin is not soft or smooth. It's plastic faux leather that makes them look like sturdy Crocs! The seams don't seem right. I really think it's not legal. Cole Haan shoes are not made in India! I will contact Cole Khan directly. See photos. Avoid.