I ordered an 8 1/2 (I can usually wear an 8 or 8 1/2). They sent me a shoe for 9 and a shoe for 10! Size 9 was "tight". Fits like a size 7 1/2 - 8. Size 10 had a nice quarter inch clearance on my heel. You look like Toms. Even the box looks real (regarding those who say they are knockoffs/fake). I've never owned a real pair of TOMS, so I can't tell if they're real or not. Another reviewer mentioned the "TM" character versus TOM's "R" character. The ones I received have NO stamp other than the TOMS name or the SKECHERS name! It has a label with a SMALL circle called Skechers. I had to take out a magnifying glass to see what was inside the circle. I don't know, but it looks like a star or an M to ME. So without having a real pair next to it to compare, I would still assume these are real fakes. Not sure if they will hold up. No one else would be able to tell from your foot that these aren't genuine TOMS, but your purchase defeats the purpose of your purchase, which is to help someone less fortunate to have a pair of shoes on their feet! But. If you buy them anyway, I would order a size up. Oh, and the ashes I ordered are dark grey. I liked the color very much. Excellent neutral. Too bad I don't trust them anymore. I am returning my mismatched pair and going to the TOMS website! I think "you get what you pay for" in this case. Revane took VERY good care of the return. No worries or headaches. As always!