I haven't read other reviews, but I've had very good experiences with insect screens and winter rugs. I'm finishing my 2nd summer with a bug screen and will be switching to a blanket soon. The only problem I've encountered is the failure of one of the fasteners that hold the grill body in place. I've replaced it with the exact element, being a little more careful, and it's worked well so far. The materials of the canopy and blanket are better than I expected, withstanding temperatures of up to 120 degrees in summer and -30 in winter at speeds over 120 km/h. I use mine on a 2007 Dodge Ram diesel pickup.