Look closely at the liquid. This is not the same as products purchased from Macy's. The bottle isn't new either, it's used. When the purchased product arrived I saw oil at the bottom and half water at the top. Macy's Clinique products do not have the same average rating. I have been using Clinique products for many years and I know the difference. Luckily I was able to get a refund for this and buy from Macy's to show you the difference.
E.L.F. Makeup Remover Pen Clear, 1 Count
15 Review
Experience The Ultimate Lash Care Routine With Our Eyelash Extension Cleanser And Foaming Cleanser Set - Paraben & Sulfate Free, Perfect For Salon And Home Use
24 Review
Eau Thermale Avene Micellar Lotion: Cleansing Water, Toning Solution, and Makeup Remover, Ideal for All Skin Types in One Product
14 Review
πΏ Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water: The Ultimate Makeup Remover for Sensitive Skin
42 Review
Unleash Your Inner Unicorn With KARIZMA'S Chunky Holographic Glitter Set - Perfect For Festivals, Raves And Makeup Artistry!
35 Review
Neem And Tea Tree Oil Balm - Soothes And Calms Dry, Itchy Skin Irritation - Oleavine TheraTree
36 Review
Smooth Skin With SOL DE JANEIRO Brazilian Bum Bum Cream
34 Review
Vitamin C Moisturizer By The Body Shop - 1.7 Oz Boost For Brighter, Healthier Skin
34 Review