Review on Caldrea Dish Soap, Biodegradable Dishwashing Liquid Made With Soap Bark And Aloe Vera, Ginger Pomelo, 16 Fl Oz (Pack Of 3) by Lisa Lopez

I purchased this same product, same scent and same size, at a local store in San Francisco and it was great, and then purchased this item from Walmart when that bottle was empty. When the package arrived from Walmart the bottles were very, very cold after being in the UPS truck. They were so cold that they left puddles of condensation on my counter as they warmed up to room temperature. I don't know if that was the cause, or if it was simply a bad batch, or if the bottles were just old, but the scent was much weaker and didn't even smell like it was the same product I had purchased in a store less than a month before- there was almost no citrus character at all. Since some of the other reviewers complain that the scent is too strong for them, there might be a problem with consistency.