Give it a 3.5 or more. There were last minute problems packing a two week trip and I had to switch from a hard top to a soft top. The main issue with this bag was that the straps were too short for an SUV with side roof racks but not transverse ones. This bag was adequate for the luggage we needed, once settled into it it was quiet (noisy in the wind at first). However, because the tension was so great, there were small tears where the strap made contact with the bag. It was low and lo and behold it was raining all the way back because it was soaking wet up front. He did his job in a short time and for little money. I bought a more expensive one, the flash broke the first time. The straps were an issue, my stuff got wet but my stuff was in a pinch.
CURT Hitch Cargo Carrier - 60 X 20-Inch Basket With 500 Lbs Capacity, Black Steel, 2-In Folding Shank
42 Review
Upgrade Your 2018-2019 Hyundai KONA With Lockable MotorFansClub Crossbars For Efficient Luggage Management (2 PCS)
26 Review
20 Cubic Feet Waterproof FieryRed Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier - Anti-Slip Mat, Travel Storage Luggage Bag Soft-Shell For All Vehicles With Or Without Rack
14 Review
MotorFansClub Roof Rack Cross Bars For Jeep Cherokee 2014-2019 | Aluminum Cargo Luggage Rail (Not Compatible With Grand Cherokee)
26 Review
4WD ORCISH Recovery Traction Boards Tracks Tire Ladder For Sand Snow Mud - Set Of 2 (2Nd Gen Bag + Mounting Pins, Black)
39 Review
Nokian Tires Nordman RS2 SUV 225/60 R18 104R winter
32 Review
Get Ultimate Towing Stability With CURT TruTrack Weight Distribution Hitch & Sway Control - Up To 10K Capacity, 2-Inch Shank & 2-5/16-Inch Ball - In Sleek Black Design
30 Review
Yokohama Ice Guard IG50 215/50 R17 99Q winter
36 Review