Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
get cozy this winter with goodthreads women's mineral wash long sleeve cardigan sweater logo

Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater Review

31

·

Very good

Revainrating 4.5 out of 5  
Rating 
4.4
👗 Women's Lingerie, Sleep & Lounge Clothing, 👗 Women's Clothing

View on AmazonView on ЯM

Media

(4)
img 1 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater
img 2 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater
img 3 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater
img 4 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater

Photos by authors

(14)
img 5 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater
img 6 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater
img 7 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater
img 8 attached to Get Cozy This Winter With Goodthreads Women'S Mineral Wash Long Sleeve Cardigan Sweater

Reviews

Global ratings 31
  • 5
    22
  • 4
    4
  • 3
    3
  • 2
    1
  • 1
    1

Type of review

Revainrating 3 out of 5

Cozy, but fades like crazy

My wife has been wanting a navy cardigan for quite some time. When she saw the opportunity to try this sweater, she was pretty excited.When the sweater arrived, she tried it on right away. It fit as expected in the girth, maybe a little bigger than a size small should. However, the length of the sweater and the sleeves was exceptionally long. We thought, being 100% cotton, it might shrink in the wash. No such luck. I don’t think the sweater shrunk at all. The length isn’t that much of an issue,

Pros
  • This sweater is well-made and fits true to size.
Cons
  • The sweater may have a strong chemical smell upon arrival

Revainrating 5 out of 5

100% cotton and very comfortable

The Goodthreads Women's Mineral Wash Open Cardigan Sweater is a very nice sweater. It is a good long length, a nice color navy, 100% cotton and very comfortable. I often wear lightweight sweaters over my long tops and this sweater is perfect. The sizing is as expected for a long and open sweater- you can easily wear it over whatever you are wearing. I like the pockets and it feels warmer than my other sweaters with nylon or linen blends.

Pros
  • Looks great, I love the blue color and the cotton used.
Cons
  • The cardigan's material may be too thin to be considered a true winter sweater

Revainrating 3 out of 5

Not Pink Carnation.

But more of a dusty rose. It’s also not light weight as described, but medium weight (which was nice). However, there was a slight tear on the side seam that grew after the initial wash on gentle cycle. I was planning on wearing in-house, so when it came out a bit misshapen and torn, I was disappointed.but decided to keep it bc I couldn’t return it post-wash and the frumpy look at home wasn’t a dealbreaker. Would not recommend based on colour & quality.

Pros
  • The color I wanted
Cons
  • The cardigan may lose its shape after repeated washings

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Beautiful, awesome quality, HEAVYWEIGHT cardi!

If it weren't for it being 100*F outside, I would wear this cardi right now! It's beautiful. I got the blue color and I think it'll go with most of what I own. The cut is nice. The length is nice. The quality is SO much better than I anticipated. It is actually 100% cotton, which seems impossible to find these days. My skin is super sensitive, so I always wash new clothes before I wear them. I just washed this cardi using the instructions on the label and it came out beautifully - no shrinkage…

Pros
  • I love this sweater! It is well made, warm.Looks good
Cons
  • The sweater may be itchy or uncomfortable against sensitive skin

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Nice sweater in my review

I have a fair amount of clothing from Good Threads and generally I am very pleased with them. They are Target quality or better. Hold up well in wash, look well-made but also affordable. I wear sweaters most of the year because the air conditioning is too high in my office and in the winter the heat isn't high enough. This is a great sweater to add to my rotation of sweaters to wear over my work clothes.

Pros
  • Two purchased as a gift (well received) and one for the lady of the house. Both happy!
Cons
  • The cardigan may shrink in the wash

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Nice Cotton Sweater

I ordered this to use at work when it gets chilly from the air conditioning or in the winter. This is a soft 100% cotton sweater. The cut or style of this is what I'd call boxy. It is not a slim fit or a form fitting sweater. I feel it runs a size large. This is navy blue and it goes with many outfits and is conservative looking. I like a sweater to layer on top of other clothing to be boxy like this and have room to move. Therefore I rate this 5 stars = Love It.

Pros
  • Everything about this sweater was great!
Cons
  • The color on this looked faded in spots. I am keeping it for around home but won’t wear it out .

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Very high quality, comfy, nice fit, unique wash.

I absolutely love this cardigan. It is a thicker knit and very warm and comfy. The cut is easy to wear and flattering. The quality of both the fabric and construction is very good, the pockets have plenty of room in them too which I love.I also really like the mineral wash look, very unique and different from other cardigans I have. This runs true to size. I normally wear between a M and L and I ordered this in an XL because I like my cardigans really oversized. This fit just like I would…

Pros
  • Love the color, fit, and overall feel! Worth every cent
Cons
  • The sweater is quite heavy and may be uncomfortable to wear for extended periods

Let me start by saying that I am very particular about my cardigans. The weight, drape, flow, neckline, and pocket placements all have to be "just so" or I won't wear it. It's rare that I find one that I love, but here it is! I received the Navy color to review and now I'm going to buy the Terra Cotta and Moss Green.The material is cotton. The description says super-lightweight, but it's more medium weight. It's not chunky at all, but would be perfect for Fall and Winter. It looks exactly like…

Pros
  • This sweater fits perfect. I have broad shoulders so I ordered one size up and I love it.
Cons
  • The sweater may not be warm enough for extremely cold temperatures

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Fading, dry flat, not "super lightweight, " but great for work

I work in a basement bookstore, and it can get cool. This sweater is PERFECT to keep in the back room. It layers over just about anything, it's cozy, and the pockets are functional.It does fade, though. In my photos, I used blue socks to to compare the color before and after washing. The photo with one blue sock is before washing the sweater; the photo with two blue socks is after washing it twice. I washed as instructed: cold water, reshape and dry flat. Noticeable fading, but I like the…

Pros
  • At Goodthreads, we are on a mission to create incredible clothes crafted with care
Cons
  • The sweater's material may not be breathable enough

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Great sweater for my opinion

I ordered the light blue in small for my Mom. It runs a little big but such a beautiful sweater. It is great for cool spring days

Pros
  • Medium weight well made color deep green
Cons
  • The cardigan's fabric may attract lint or pet hair

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Happy with my choice

It's the weight I expected, not too light not too heavy. I like the length and color, happy with my choice. That's my feedback.

Pros
  • It’s good for winter
Cons
  • The sweater's sleeves may be too long or too short for some wearers

Revainrating 3 out of 5

Not as dressy as hoped

Nice and heavy, warm, comfortable. The mineral wash makes it faded looking , and not as dressy as the picture makes it appear, but it's a nice sweater.

Pros
  • …from my daughter. It’s comfortable and sturdy as well as flattering.
Cons
  • Estaba en malas condiciones,quiero mi dinero de vuelta

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Great layering piece for chillier weather

This is the sweater I’ll be wearing for evening dog walks when it gets chilly, to have ready for overly air-conditioned spaces in summer, and to snuggle in on the couch with a book. The cardigan is 100% cotton and medium weight. In certain lights, it has an attractive subtle sheen. You can pick the size according to the way you want it to fit: your usual size for a traditional look or a larger size for a slouchier, casual style. Two front pockets are convenient for holding a cell phone or keys.

Pros
  • Love the fit , flattening,light, very comfortable
Cons
  • The cardigan may be too bulky to layer comfortably under a coat

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Amazing Quality good for me

An absolutely beautiful sweater! Such good, thick material, and such good quality! I am considering buying another color because I love this one so much.

Pros
  • Not many sweaters in this color. It works great with all my olive green patterns
Cons
  • The sweater may not fit well on all body types

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Beautiful!: my feedback

Beautiful sweater and absolutely love the color. Thanks for attention. So comfortable for every day wear! Highly recommended.

Pros
  • Love the weight and material. thick but not too thick and looks very nice. yellow is a perfect yellow.
Cons
  • The cardigan's mineral wash design may not be to everyone's taste

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Nice shape not flimsy

This is exactly how it looks in the picture. Sort of a washed look, slightly thicker knit. It is a boxy cut, and fits nicely. It was a little thick for my summer needs.

Pros
  • Everything about this sweater was awesome. I bought a large and it fit perfect
Cons
  • Not very soft.

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Thick and warm for my opinion

Let me first start by saying- wow. This one was a good find. For several reasons. 1. It’s actually not a light-weight cardigan. It’s very heavy. Because it is knitted. It’s super thick and I wouldn’t say it could serve as a jacket but it could definitely be warm in a cold falls morning. 2. It’s tight where you want it to be and loose where you need it to be. It didn’t smell bad when I received it, and after washing it one time it still stayed tight where I wanted it to. This would be perfect…

Pros
  • Not as dark navy as I wanted, but nice fabric and fit.
Cons
  • The cardigan may have a tendency to stretch out over time

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Nice color. in my review

This is okay, not great, but I like the moss green color and was looking for a casual green cardigan for weekends. Definitely size down. I’m usually a small or medium in cardigans but ended up exchanging for an XS and it’s still a bit oversized.

Pros
  • Comfortable and versatile, this sweater is perfect on its own or as a layer under a blazer or jacket
Cons
  • The cardigan may be too expensive for some buyers

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Great sweater! best in my review

This is a great quality sweater. I'm loving all the mineral wash sweaters from Goodthreads right now. The material of this sweater is sturdy, not soft exactly, but still comfortable. Medium-heavy and warm. It has a nice drape to it, and the slightly worn look of the mineral wash is nice. It's a deep navy, with slightly black/gray undertones. I'm 5'2", 110lbs and my usual size XS fit perfectly. Will be a great multi-season sweater.

Pros
  • 100% Cotton
Cons
  • The sweater may be too tight or too loose in certain areas

Revainrating 2 out of 5

Needs Work for my opinion

I have a Goodthreads long buttondown that I love so I was looking forward to trying this cardigan. Unfortunately, after washing the first wash it looks worn. Not in the sense of pilling, but fading at the edges, the color looking a bit off in places, and looking a bit stretched out at the bottom (I did follow the washing and drying instructions.) It has pockets which I like, but it also ha a slits at the bottom which I dkn't like. They don't make for a flattering fit and they also reduce how…

Pros
  • Works well with all outfits I love the fabric and weight is perfect for early spring and fall
Cons
  • The cardigan may be too long or too short for some wearers