I have 5 hungry dogs, and only 2 would eat them. After a bit the 3rd wanted it just out of competition but spit it out several times before eating it and then left the area where I was treating from. Good ingredients but need some bacon or flavor change to make it more desirable to eat. Even my dogs that normally just swallow snacks were not sure about it for a bit. Very good product just need to be able to feed it to them.