These hoses seem to be of pretty good quality and fit my 2011 Mini Clubman S well, albeit tightly. They are something larger than OEM hoses so clamps barely fit. I would consider buying new clamps if doing the job again. There's also a hose that I haven't put on yet (I haven't finished the work yet) that I'm not entirely sure how it holds. I'm pretty sure it needs to be cut, but it doesn't look as similar in shape to the OEM hose as the others. It was my fault too, but it wasn't really theβ¦