🧊 W&P Extra Large Charcoal Cube Tray - Single Review

Why do I like the Peak Large Ice Cube Tray? The product is well built. It has a durable top edge that keeps the soft silicone from wobbling. I can fill it with water and put it in the freezer without spilling a drop. The cubes are very easy to take out, one at a time or several, depending on your preference. The cubes are the perfect size for my cocktail glasses. Larger cubes last longer than ice cubes. I've had it for a few years now and use it every day and it's still like new. I gave away a…

Here I answer questions I had questions about. Does that thing smell? After washing, it has no characteristic odor. Does the lid open? As you can see from my photos there is only one piece of silicone that sits on top but it doesn't prevent water from spilling. Will the ice cubes be perfectly square? As you can see in my second photo there is no support on the sides so the ice cubes are square but slightly convex. What I like about this item so far is that it makes great ice cubes, the silicone

I originally considered buying this item because it has a lid. My old open tray always produced cubes with a "freeze smell" so I liked the idea of putting a lid on it. I also liked that it has an internal frame that helps keep it stable when placed in the freezer. I thought it was overpriced but when I saw 128 5 star reviews I decided to pull the trigger. However, after using it I was very disappointed. The main benefit - the "lid" - is nothing more than a silicone mat cut out to rest on the…