Tag is heavy and sturdy, the ring attaching it has held up perfectly fine and does not feel flimsy. Both have gotten wet when I forgot to take it off before he jumped into the lake and neither tarnished. We've been using it for a few weeks now and there are no scratches or wear and tear from the other tags on his ring (rabies, etc), which is more than I expected. Really beautiful rose gold color, definitely a pretty large tag so I wouldn't suggest it for toy dogs, but it's not particularly "See full review