This hammer feels great and would look incredible if it hadn't arrived with numerous chips on the black surface. I know it will stain and chip with use, but it should be in the best condition when new. I also ordered 19 oz with chopped nut and they also came in the same condition. Both replacement units arrived in the same condition. They were all bubble wrapped so I don't think this happened during delivery to me. I would give these hammers 5 stars if it weren't for the surface chips. I wonder if the rest of the finish will come out easily.