Before then, I rode standard urban models, but I yearned for a machine that was more forgiving of light off-roading. Due to extensive travel requirements this summer, we constructed a dacha. I was under the impression that A/T would be more fuel inefficient due to their tread, but I did not notice any difference in my own driving. And the guardian itself is a thing of beauty. Very good at getting rid of water, looks great, and cleans itself. Definitely go for the SUV option.