Finally found a tape that sticks! I used this to stick plastic sheeting around a foam mattress and stick to the plastic just fine but not enough that i could pull it off to readjust it.
Gorilla Tough And Wide Silver Duct Tape, 2.88" X 25Yd - Pack Of 1 For Superior Strength And Durability
23 Review
TapePlus Gaffer Tape - Large 2 Inch X 40 Yards Roll - Versatile Black Tape For Gaffers, Ducts, Floors, And More
31 Review
Industrial-Strength Double-Sided Woodworking Tape, 4"X30 Yards Yellow CNC Machine Tape For Woodworkers And Crafters - Removable Woodturner'S Tape From XFasten
52 Review
High Tensile Strength Duct Tape Silver, 5.8mils, 2 Inches x 50 Yards - All-Weather Duct Repair Tape for Commercial Use, Heavy-Duty Repair, Packing with Temperature and Shear Stress Resistance - XFasten
39 Review