Goods received. The box is intact but the back protection is scratched and worn. I almost scratched them, but for $45 I don't want them already scratched. In order to get a replacement, I now have to send them all back, not just the rear ones. The quality was good but I expect the new parts to be free of scratches or dents. Seems my fall was a fluke as everyone else seems to be doing fine. Update: They send me new replacement parts and I no longer have to send back fenders that aren't scratched. I am very satisfied with the timely resolution of the problem.